Tuesday, December 22, 2015

Have a Holly Jolly (and Consumerist yet Discerning) Christmas


 
These days, we’re all savvy and jaded enough to see through the misdirection of television commercials. Nonetheless, a passage about advertising in the following video caught my attention. The video is part of a series called The School of Life and summarizes the thought of Frankfurt School philosopher Theodor Adorno. It covers a lot of ground, but it isn’t long. I recommend watching the whole thing, but watch for the bit about advertising, which begins at 4:10.

 
Here's the part that jumped out at me:
“When they’re trying to sell us something, advertisers show us the thing that we really want and then connect it to something we don’t actually need. So we can see an advert showing a group of friends walking on a beach chatting amiably or a family having a picnic and laughing warmly together. These adverts show us these things because they know we crave community and connection, but the industrial economy prefers to keep us lonely and consuming, so at the end of the adverts, we’ll be urged to buy some 25-year-old whiskey or a car so powerful that no road would ever let us legally drive it at top speed.”

Advertisements do many things and one of the things they do is show us something we need in our innermost being in order to sell us something that we don’t need. Coming up with examples is easy, especially in this season when every business and corporation this side of the Industrial Revolution is trying to cash in on Christmas and financial news reports constantly tell us it is our duty to shop in order to drive up holiday sales.

Consider this Coca-Cola commercial:

 
This advertisement is full of much that we all want and need. The words kindness and joy appear in written form. We see young couples holding hands, children playing, families bonding and friends smiling. Everyone looks physically fit. A red balloon takes flight from a vending machine and drifts over a quaint plaza. Christmas gifts fall into strangers’ hands, thereby linking disparate lives against the alienating forces of modern life. The community comes together and marvels, and we are encouraged to share that old Platonic concept the Good.

Which one of us does not want such communion with our fellows? Who would pass up a chance to fall in love again? Which one of us would not like to exude such physical and spiritual well-being? Who among us does not hunger to reclaim the sense of magic we held in our youth? Who would not like to rise like the Charioteer in Plato’s Phaedrus commanding his winged steeds to climb ever higher, leaving the earth below to see with clarity the Forms and even the light of the Good?

Coca-Cola’s marketers show us these things because we need them. And they do this to sell us something no one needs: a carbonated soft drink.

Philosopher Slavoj Zizek talks about Coca-Cola in the documentary The Pervert’s Guide to Ideology (2012):

 
For Zizek, when Coca-Cola offers us “The Real Thing,” it is offering to give us l’objet petit a, the object cause of desire described in Lacanian psychoanalytic theory. The objet petit a is what we think we want, but it doesn’t really exist, so we forever circle but never grasp it. You may think you want that new car, promotion or paramour, but once you have it, are you sated? Of course not. The object cause of desire switches to something else, so you stay driven, struggling for satisfaction that, due to the makeup of our psyche, is impossible.

Pringles is so sly that its classic advertising slogan explicitly states this, keeping the objet petit a in a cycle focused solely on its own product, from chip to chip: Once you pop, you can’t stop.

But are all advertisements merely a satisfying spin on a product that ultimately provides little satisfaction? Isn’t it possible that a product satisfies what its advertisements promise? Here’s a recent commercial for the video game Star Wars Battlefront:

 
Open with palpable estrangement: a man sits bored at his desk dreaming of his childhood. Once upon a time, he and his buddy drew pictures of their action figures, they had lightsaber battles with flashlights, and they dressed up as Star Wars characters for Halloween. Those were the days . . . Then suddenly his buddy shows up in an X-Wing, he busts out of his office, boards his own fighter with its own astromech copilot (R2D2 no less!), and goes to take out some Imperial AT-ATs.

At first, this appears to be no more substantial than the Coca-Cola commercial. On that reading, this commercial offers what you really want--friendship, adventure, a sense of purpose and fulfillment--while actually offering you cheap entertainment.

But wait!

In today’s world, a video game can actually be the medium through which people connect. Through online and cooperative missions, Star Wars Battlefront allows players to meet and play with strangers, or play together with your favorite mop-headed childhood buddy. And while the adventures are all virtual, this has always been the nature of storytelling and takes nothing away from the magic. Star Wars and other franchises are no less inspiring to many than the plays of Euripides once were to Athenians, or Beowulf to the Anglo-Saxons. Star Wars Battlefront isn’t exactly necessary, but it has the potential to facilitate some things we truly need.

I’m more skeptical that a can of Coca-Cola can be as successful at slaking spiritual thirst, but perhaps I’m being too harsh. How many cans of Mr. Pibb have I enjoyed with friends over tabletop RPGs, sharing laughs and having a hell of a time? The beverage was a part of that, a part of our subculture, our fraternity.

As usual, I see the value in multiple perspectives, but that can be a good thing. I guarantee you will watch television this Christmas season, see the same commercials over and over until you want to start chucking nutcracker soldiers at the screen, and spend too much money on crap for yourself and others. In today’s world, you can’t help but be a consumer, which is to say a stooge to the boob tube, but you can also remember to check yourself, see through the haze of price tags and twinkling lights, and seek a holiday experience that holds something more authentic.

 

Thursday, December 17, 2015

When the World Loses a Voice

 
"The world was losing its voices—the ones that mattered anyway."

 When I heard that rock singer Scott Weiland had been found dead on his tour bus, I immediately thought of the above line from a short story I wrote on the day Norman Mailer died. Weiland’s cause of death was cardiac arrest. He was 48.

Like many music lovers, I was thrilled when pop music began to give way to alternative music, especially grunge, in the early Nineties, and the band Scott Weiland fronted was an important part of that movement. The first song by Stone Temple Pilots that I remember hearing was “Plush” (1993). It showcased Weiland’s throaty vocals and was one of a string of hits I would hear countless times on local alternative radio stations in the years to come.

 
Weiland’s voice was one that established a place in my life. Soon after STP’s sophomore album Purple (1994) came out, a friend and I ducked out of a church sleepover--after a day of tearing down houses destroyed by flooding--to go see STP at the state fair. Those were the days when they would bring out a couch, rocking chair, side table and lamp for a cozy acoustic set midway through the show. Laid-back. Stripped down. Just chilling. This was part of the zeitgeist.

And it was exquisite.

Not long before, the world had lost another one of its voices when Kurt Cobain committed suicide by shooting himself in the head with a shotgun. I was sitting with friends in a college lounge when another friend (the guitarist in a band for which I tried to and occasionally succeeded at playing drums) came in and told us the news. We were all shocked, but Cobain had been a personal hero for him, so he took it the hardest.

It’s a moment I’ll never forget, just like I’ll never forget the first time I heard “Smells Like Teen Spirit.” In my corner of the world, Nirvana had yet to break when the song was released in 1991, but MTV had a late-night program which I remember showing videos for The Posies, Frank Black and others, many of whom would soon be eclipsed in the public eye by bands like Stone Temple Pilots, Pearl Jam, Soundgarden, Smashing Pumpkins and Nirvana.

It was on this program that I first heard and saw the video for “Smells Like Teen Spirit,” and it resonated with a rebellious streak in me. My high school’s dances were quaint affairs in the gym, with oldies like “Unchained Melody” by The Righteous Brothers getting the couples out on the floor. Good memories, but “Smells Like Teen Spirit,” with its fuzzy guitars, banging drums, mumbled lyrics, smoky atmosphere, creepy janitor and anarchy cheerleaders delivered a subversive thrill.

Cobain may have mumbled many of his lyrics as if he didn’t give a fuck, but as his life and death showed, he gave too much of one, something which I suspect was also true of another tragic hero from those days. Alice in Chains is probably my favorite of the bands I’m mentioning in this post, so it was lead singer Lane Staley’s death by drug overdose in 2002 that most deeply affected me. By then, I was a working adult and felt like an important piece of my youth had chipped and fallen away.

Staley’s voice had been with me since I had picked up Facelift (1990) on cassette from the local music hole-in-the-wall one day while out trekking around town with a friend. Soon after, AIC played second to last on the main stage at Lollapalooza (previous post). The band was just beginning to perform songs from its second studio album Dirt (1992). On the heavier songs, sweaty masses seethed on the hill behind where I sat with a couple friends, and a constant barrage of tossed bottles and other refuse arced back and forth overhead.

The point of these recollections is that Cobain, Stayley and Weiland were a part of my life, and depending on your music tastes, may have been an important part of yours, too. That’s why their deaths affect us so much and we offer tributes to them on social media, even though we know their lifestyles were often less than model.

 
Weiland’s troubles with alcohol and drugs, and his shaky relationships with bandmates, are well documented. His family life was also troubled. Immediately after his death, his ex-wife Mary Forsberg Weiland wrote a piece for Rolling Stone cautioning against glorifying his death:
"In reality, what you [the fans] didn't want to acknowledge was a paranoid man who couldn't remember his own lyrics and who was only photographed with his children a handful of times in 15 years of fatherhood."

Nonetheless, glorify we will. We will celebrate troubled artists in all fields--Jack Kerouac and David Foster Wallace, Jackson Pollock and Mark Rothko, Marilyn Monroe and Heath Ledger, Amy Winehouse and Scott Weiland. But hopefully we will celebrate them not as saints but as flawed individuals who brought beauty into the world, a beauty that entered our lives.

So, when the world loses voices that you love, post R.I.P. messages on social media, buy a T-shirt, download an album, or find some other way to pay tribute--for you celebrate your own life as well as theirs.

 

Monday, December 14, 2015

Mad Max: Out of Eden (4/5)


Note: This is Part 4 in a projected five-part series analyzing Mad Max: Fury Road. Links to previous posts can be found at the bottom of this one.

 
Interpretation often involves using different lenses, not only to highlight present features but also to give a tone to the subject. For this post on Mad Max: Fury Road, I’m going to use a biblical lens: the Christian myth of fall and redemption.

 
Out of Eden

The tale of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden begins a scriptural cycle that relates the fall of man. Once, man and woman lived in paradise. They were near God and knew no shame or suffering. The only act forbidden them was eating of the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, but they--of course--do exactly that, causing their creator to cast them out, consigning them to a life of tribulation. Man must sweat for his bread. Woman must suffer in childbirth. Never again shall either know the bliss from whence they came. (Genesis 2:8-3:24)

The opening narration of Fury Road raises this theme:
My name is Max. My world is fire and blood. Once, I was a cop, a road warrior searching for a righteous cause. As the world fell, each of us in our own way was broken. It was hard to know who was more crazy: me or everyone else.
The fall in the world of Mad Max is one of ecological disaster brought on by war. In the first film, the old world--a green one where people enjoyed domestic bliss and a relatively orderly society--is still visible.  It is gone by the second film, and by Fury Road, so estranged are the characters from plant life that the War Boy called Nux refers to a tree as “that thing over there.” Yet many characters still yearn to return to the world before the fall. In Fury Road, Imperator Furiosa tells the Wives that she will take them to “the green place.” Alas, she finds this paradise--one endangered in our own world--no longer exists.

The Book of Genesis has no shortage of tales blaming humanity for its own problems. Consider the story of Cain and Abel, which I also detect in--overlay onto?--Fury Road. Cain was a sheepherder and his brother Abel was a tiller of the soil. Cain was angry when God showed respect for Abel’s offering but dissed his own, so he slew his brother and lied about it to God. For this, God punished him. Turning to the KJV, because it always sounds the coolest, we find the following:
And the LORD said unto Cain, Where is Abel thy brother? And he said, I know not: Am I my brother's keeper? And he said, What hast thou done? the voice of thy brother's blood crieth unto me from the ground. And now art thou cursed from the earth, which hath opened her mouth to receive thy brother's blood from thy hand; When thou tillest the ground, it shall not henceforth yield unto thee her strength; a fugitive and a vagabond shalt thou be in the earth. (Genesis 4: 9-12)
Just as Cain killed out of envy, so the powers of the earth in Mad Max warred over natural resources. Furthermore, Cain and his descendants, like those who have inherited the sands in the film, are cursed to a life coaxed from barren soil. Cain’s progeny are forced to wander, like the scavengers in Mad Max who cruise for a bite to eat, a quart of fuel, a piece of flesh.

Further along the downward spiral of human being, Genesis tells of the Tower of Babel. Humankind, in its vanity, sought to erect a structure that would reach to Heaven. For this presumption, the Almighty declared he would “confound the language of all the earth.” No longer able to communicate, the children of men gave up their endeavor and scattered to the four corners of the earth. (Genesis 11:1-9)

While almost everyone speaks English in Mad Max, the Buzzards in Fury Road speak Russian, Latin pops up here and there, and the War Boys have developed their own, sometimes unintelligible, slang. And who, having seen Mad Max: Beyond Thunderdome, can forget the curious speech of the Lost Tribe? As Mad Max’s world continues to spin, its denizens will continue to wander, they will further group by language, and new lingos will evolve.

 
Back to Eden

Could, however, the way through be the only way out of this post-apocalyptic nightmare?

Christian theology teaches that while suffering may seem to discount the existence of a benevolent and all-powerful deity (previous post), God has a plan. In the end, all of creation will be redeemed through the sacrifice of Christ on the cross. I haven’t gone digging through the Mad Max films for Christ-like figures--novelists and screenwriters love those, so they may be there--but personal redemption is a clear theme of the series.

Max Rockatansky’s struggle for redemption runs through all the films. He begins the series as a highway officer in the Main Force Patrol. He fights crime by day but at night goes home to a wife and child. When highway marauders kill his family, he blames himself--in his words, he is “haunted by those he could not protect”--and falls into madness as the world crumbles around him.

Mad Max 2: The Road Warrior and Beyond Thunderdome both hold out the hope that Max will recover his humanity, but at the beginning of Fury Road, he has gone feral. His hair and beard are long, he’s filthy, he stomps on a lizard and jams it in his mouth. For most of the film, he barely speaks, and when he does, his speech is clipped and broken. It’s as if he’s forgotten how to speak, how to connect with other human beings.

Furiosa is another character seeking redemption. We know because she says so:

 
She cannot have risen to drive a War Rig for the despot Immortan Joe without having committed some unsavory acts along the way. The movie tells us little other than that her soul is in a bad way, and she sees helping Joe’s Wives escape as a means of atonement.

Later, as the heroes discuss taking over the Citadel where Immortan Joe rules, Max raises redemption again:
Keeper of the Seeds: I like this plan. We could start again, just like the old days!

Max: Look, it'll be a hard day. But I guarantee you that a hundred and sixty days’ ride that way, there's nothing but salt. At least that way we might be able to . . . together . . . come across some kind of redemption. 
Turning the Citadel into a new home, where there is water, agriculture and safety, would mean redemption for Furiosa and Max--and a return to humanity’s Edenic origin. The very scene of Furiosa’s shame, Max’s imprisonment, and the Wives’ hell of rape and forced impregnation would be transformed into the closest thing to Heaven. And where, in Christian teaching, is the Kingdom of Heaven established?

On earth, of course--the erstwhile den of sin. (Revelation 21:1-4)

Personal redemption is one thing, but does director George Miller have plans for his entire creation? Does he have a way to reverse what nuclear war and environmental collapse have wrought? A way to remove all that sand or at least push it back? A way to fill the seas with water? To bring forth fruit from the earth? To gather the scattered human race back into civilization?

I don’t know, and I’m not sure I’d be interested in that story. Everybody knows that what happens between birth and death--between Fall and final Grace--is where life happens. That’s where it all goes down and you either face it . . . or go mad.

I love connections between different canons, but am I discovering what is in the text or am I putting it there? As my citations from the movie illustrate, Fury Road leaves no room for doubt on some of these points. I suspect, however, that I have also colored the material with the tint of my lens, and it wouldn’t surprise me if readers have thought at times along the way, “He’s totally forcing that into the movie!”

But that doesn’t matter. We can only access a text--a book, a painting, an sci-fi film--through our experience of it, and experience requires both object and subject. Both bring something to the table, and the play between them is the stuff of interpretation.

 
Previous posts in this series:
Mad Max Feminista (1/5)
Jennifer Blood Feminista (2/5)
Mad Max: Of Hawks and Doves (3/5)
 






 

Tuesday, December 8, 2015

Mad Max: Of Hawks and Doves (3/5)


Note: This is Part 3 in a projected five-part series analyzing Mad Max: Fury Road. Links to previous posts can be found at the bottom of this one. The first three posts deal heavily with feminism, while Parts 5 and 6 will explore other topics.


When I wrote my first two posts on Mad Max: Fury Road and feminism, I was too easy on Feminist Frequency founder Anita Sarkeesian for saying the film is not feminist. Upon a second viewing, the feminist message in Fury Road is even more obvious. However, rather than list all the evidence for this, I would like to focus on the contrast between men as warlike and women as peaceful that runs through the film.

The villain Immortan Joe keeps young women prisoner in a giant safe. They are known as the Wives and serve as breeders for his children. By now, anyone who has seen the movie or paid attention to the buzz knows that when they escape they leave behind the message “WE ARE NOT THINGS.” With the Blu-Ray to pause, I was struck by the other messages that appear briefly: “WHO KILLED THE WORLD?” and “OUR BABIES WILL NOT BE WARLORDS.”

Both of these messages point to men as responsible for war--and this has been a recurring theme in real-world feminism over the years. The world of Mad Max is a post-apocalyptic one, and Fury Road tells us the world died due to wars, most likely nuclear, over resources. The Wives’ answer to the question of who killed the world is obvious: men did. Men cannot refrain from conquering territory, as well as women, through force.

“OUR BABIES WILL NOT BE WARLORDS” echoes this condemnation. Immortan Joe’s children become, like most men under his rule, soldiers known as War Boys, and what they lack in emotional complexity, they compensate for with focused bellicosity. Stoked on blood transfusions and the cult surrounding their leader, they are pure, gleeful aggression:

Point and shoot.

On the other hand, the film portrays women in terms of maternal characteristics--with some of their roles, as in our own world, imposed. The Wives give birth. Another group of Joe’s prisoners known as the Mothers produce milk. Like the stereotypical housewife of the Fifties, they stay at home--think April Wheeler in Revolutionary Road or Betsy Draper in Mad Men--while the men go out to business or battle. True, Imperator Furiosa, the true star of Fury Road, is the baddest of Joe’s badasses, but for this, she seeks redemption.

Men bad. Women good. We’ve heard all this before.

So it is refreshing, and stands out, when Fury Road challenges these depictions of men and women. When the War Rig in which Furiosa and the other escapees are fleeing becomes bogged down, Max grabs some explosives and struts out into the dark toward their pursuers. The Wife known as Toast the Knowing asks, “Whattaya suppose he’s gonna do?” Furiosa replies, “Retaliate first.” She assumes, her disappointment obvious, that Max is going to repay violence with violence--in the manner of retaliatory nuclear strikes--instead of doing something more productive for the group.
 
 
Max surprises her by coming back with gear they sorely need. Max did fight, but not out of bloodthirst. His motives were altruistic for the benefit of his new family. This is an unmistakable insertion on the part of the filmmakers to show that men are not always merely road warriors: sometimes they too care about hearth and home.

The film also makes a point of contradicting the assumption that women are peaceful. Furiosa and co. encounter old women living in the desert who have survived by killing men. An old sniper known as Keeper of the Seeds says, “Killed everyone I've ever met out here. Head shots all of them--snap! Right on the medulla.” The Wife known as The Dag is at first scornful of this. She replies, “I thought some of you girls were above all that.”

These scenes make a point of contradicting the Wives’ assumptions--and our own, indoctrinated as we are by feminist critiques that often paint in cartoonish strokes--that men are brutish while women are compassionate.

Mad Max creator, screenwriter and director George Miller is to be commended for a movie engaging in feminist discourse through what at first glance is the type of blow-’em-up traditionally branded “guy stuff.” His genius, however, is on full display as at the same time he critiques feminist tropes and, characteristically, subverts them. To view Mad Max: Fury Road as merely, in Sarkeesian’s words, “a cinematic orgy of male violence” is an accurate statement of her own assumptions going into the theater, but is a questionable summarization of the movie.

 
Previous posts in this series:
Mad Max Feminista (1/5)
Jennifer Blood Feminista (2/5)

Friday, November 13, 2015

Birdman or (The Artsy-Fartsy Vice of Snobbishness)


I would recommend anyone to see Birdman or (The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance). Director Alejandro Iñárritu is at the top of his craft and pushing Hollywood’s boundaries in ways that few directors today even attempt. It’s engrossing and unforgettable, but it also bugs me.

 
Forget for a moment the gripping drama about a man wrestling with his demons. Forget about the moving personal relationships. Forget about the cluttered labyrinthine and claustrophobic sets. Forget about all that loud, jazzy drumming that is the score. Forget about Michael Keaton’s bold comeback to the limelight. Forget about the intensity of the performances by Ed Norton and Naomi Watts (longtime favorites of mine), and the lovely fragility of Andrea Riseborough (also excellent in Oblivion), and about Emma Stone’s portrayal of a girl with self-destructive tendencies (a performance that won me over). Forget about the surrealism, which jars us and carries us with it when it soars. Forget the poignant exploration of acting in all its torment, and about its accompaniment, a sharp critique of Hollywood and Broadway. Forget the uncanny way the story overlaps the real-life career of its lead actor. Ignore all the signs that Alejandro Iñárritu--whose previous body of work signified as early as 1999 with Amores Perros the arrival of an artist of singular vision--has reached a new pinnacle in his career, making him a master of cinema for all time, nay, eternity. And forget about all those awards, justly won, too many to count, really, with probably a few more hiding around somewhere. Forget all of that for a moment and let me tell you what bugs me about Birdman.

Mainly, it’s snobby.

I enjoyed Birdman when I saw it in the theater, but the recurring insults to superhero movies bothered me. This is no casual slight. It’s a recurring theme, and a timely one given the ubiquity of superhero cinema and television in recent years. This isn’t the post to explain why I think superhero fiction is often richer than a lot of supposedly high art, but the script of Birdman often refers to comic book movies as if they are cheap art for dumb masses, compared to real art by real artists. The scriptwriters appear to fancy themselves the latter and look down their noses at low art, its practitioners and its audiences. And that’s snobby.

Birdman is also hard on critics. In the film, actor Riggan Thomson confronts one in a bar as she works on a review:

 
Fellow actor Mike Shiner is more succinct in his judgement:
“A man becomes a critic when he cannot be an artist, the same way that a man becomes an informer when he cannot be a soldier.”
This is an attack on all critics. They’re all just a bunch of withered souls, creatively impotent, who heap scorn on the beautiful spirits who are actors. Birdman drips with scorn for such as these, but where would the arts be without their penumbra of critique, reviews, interpretation and awards? And what are we lowly viewers--chowing on nachos as we watch the Blu-Ray--but private critics? The way Birdman comes across, one would think that the only ones who count are those who make art, not those who experience the product. But the object of art is also for its subjects, from viewers at home to stuffy critics.

Making matters worse is the way Birdman undercuts its own snobbish claims. The crux of the movie is that Riggan is struggling to be a real artist. He’s putting his life on the line in an artsy Broadway play after years as a washed-up has-been who once struck it big with a couple superhero flicks. We are given to believe such a comeback is nearly impossible, and yet the character is played by an actor who struck it big with a couple superhero flicks (somewhat artsy ones no less) and is making exactly that comeback before our eyes in this very film.

Birdman’s success casts further doubt on its claims. The film often portrays critics, the average viewer and Hollywood as too Philistine to appreciate true art such as Iñárritu’s, and yet all of Iñárritu’s films--from Amores Perros through Birdman have been successful, finding audiences and acclaim. It would be thankless indeed to stick your finger in the eye of those who value you and contribute to your success.

As I write this, however, I realize that while Birdman’s criticism of superhero movies and critics is fairly thoroughgoing, it has many characters and situations that challenge the snobbery of the artsy-fartsy class. In fact, the tension between artists’ visions of grandeur and their feet of clay (the real world where, in the words of Emma Stone’s character, “nobody gives a shit”) is central to the movie’s themes and shows that Iñárritu and others behind Birdman are aware of their own pretension. This multiplicity of viewpoints is part of what makes much of Iñárritu’s work--I think particularly of Babel--so great.

And great Birdman is. At its best, it is film-making at its finest--so its Academy Award for Best Picture is well-deserved. But it still bugs me, because at its worst, it’s myopic and snobby. In saying so, I suppose I’m just another critic, but this critic refuses to take that label as a dirty word.
 

Saturday, November 7, 2015

Religion and Atheism Abound in Bollywood's PK


 
When the alien known as PK arrives on Earth, the first thing that happens is a man in the desert steals his device for phoning home, leaving him stranded. Hearing that god is the answer to all troubles, PK goes on a search for god. He encounters the people and practices of many faiths and makes friends and enemies along the way.

So goes the plot of the 2014 Bollywood hit film PK, which turns out to be--at least on one level--a surprising statement of atheism from an industry known for strict conventions and from a country known for religious conservatism.
 
(Sorry, this trailer is in Hindi, but you can find a trailer and the movie in English on iTunes.)

 
The plot hearkens back to any number of stories in which an extraterrestrial comes to Earth and, baffled by our curious Earthling ways, teaches us about ourselves and reveals new ways of being. I think of Robert Heinlein’s most influential novel Stranger in a Strange Land (1961), in which Valentine Michael Smith, a human being raised by Martians, encounters terrestrial estrangement and teaches us to grok love. And consider David Bowie’s classic album The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars (1972), in which a rock-and-roller serves as the conduit for messages from alien beings to humanity five years before the world is to end due to human excess.

With its critique of religion, PK is more in the vein of Heinlein. The titular alien’s encounters with con men as well as believers rarely end well, for the religious always seem to be concerned with decidedly unholy concerns: power, money and exceptionalism. Their methods are also questionable: blind faith, trickery and violence. These aspects of religion are familiar to all of us, whether through reports of Islamist terror in the daily news or through passing the collection plate each Sunday in church. In PK’s words:
“The god you made up is just like you: petty, takes bribes, makes false promises, readily meets the rich, keeps the poor waiting, thrives on flattery, makes you live in fear [. . .] The god you believe in, abolish him.“
On the surface, PK’s message is that old distinction between religion versus spirituality. Its proponents assert the superiority of vague spirituality and decry stuffy religious dogma while almost always subscribing to the traditional superstitions that make up the latter. This position sounds genial, open-minded and subversive, which is why people like it, but actually it subverts nothing, which is, I suspect, why the makers of PK chose it as the superficial message of their film. They could appear to criticize organized religion and avoid offending the masses while on another level also advancing . . .

. . . atheism.

The film makes several arguments against religion that are regularly employed by atheists in debates against Christian apologists--such as how the truth claims of competing religions contradict each other--but the key argument in the film appears during a standoff on national television between PK and the guru Tapasvi. The guru adopts a typical apology for religion:
“What do you want, huh? A world without God? Do you have any clue how people suffer? No food to eat, no place to live, no friend to talk to . . .  People kill themselves, slit their wrists, jump off buildings . . .  Why? Because they have no hope. If bowing before God, smearing holy ash, and wearing amulets gives them hope to live, then who are you to snatch away that hope? And if you snatch away their God, how will you fill that void?”
PK’s answer is oddly indirect--and even endorses Enlightenment-style Deism--but viewers are sure to think of a more direct response to the guru’s challenge. Throughout the film, we have watched PK suffer, and it was real people, often strangers, who gave him food and shelter and became his friends. He himself at one point gives the only money he has to a poor man who needs it to pay for a meal on his wife’s birthday. The film is bursting with religion, but not once does it depict any supernatural event large or small--not so much as a holy glow or miraculous chance turn of events. Instead, what it shows is human goodness without the need for gods or their self-proclaimed mediators on Earth.

In other words, secular humanism.

This is one answer to which many like myself have turned in response to the death of God. As a life stance, it has the benefit of being an observable practice with tangible results. People can help people, and indeed they often do--no god necessary. Why is it that the religious must do good in the name of God instead of just doing good?

I’ve watched very little Bollywood and I only watched PK because most of the other offerings on board a long flight didn’t look interesting, but it turned out to be laugh-out-loud funny, romantic and thought-provoking. PK criticizes religion and shows that real acts of human kindness can fill the void left by an imaginary god’s disappearance.
 
 

Tuesday, October 27, 2015

Return of the Living Eighties


Popular music has a case of the Eighties, and nothing exemplifies this more than the phenomenal success of Taylor Swift’s album 1989. As I write this, the digital download continues to sit in Amazon’s top ten best-selling albums exactly a full year after its release. The vanguard of this trend recasts Eighties music through the sensibilities of twentysomethings and markets it for teens today, which to my mind raises a question: What is someone who lived through the year 1989 to think?

I was raised to despise synthesizers, drum machines and studio effects in favor of real people playing real instruments, and there were plenty such musicians in 1989. The three biggies in my circle of friends were Violent Femmes, R.E.M. and U2. Singles from R.E.M.’s Green (1988, video) were all over the radio and 3 (1989, video) was the most mature work from Violent Femmes yet, but it was U2’s 1988 release Rattle and Hum (previous post, video) that most electrified us. We wore out the cassettes in our Walkmans, passed around bootleg VHS copies of the documentary, and strove in vain to have holey jeans as cool as The Edge’s.

In short, I would not have touched music like Taylor Swift’s with a ten-foot pole.

But while Taylor Swift’s haters are legion (and decisively losing the battle), she engenders no such dislike in me. The alternative music boom in the early to mid-Nineties was bliss, but as an adult I’ve branched out. I recently wrote a series of posts on hip-hop music (here), the only live performances I’ve attended in recent years have been either opera or heavy metal, and the only music on my Amazon Wishlist at the moment is Selena Gomez’s Revival. The truth is, with such eclectic taste, I’m more inclined to enjoy bubblegum pop now than ever before.

I first noticed the return of the Eighties sound when my son, who was three at the time, began enjoying what he called “the banana song” on the radio. This was Charlie XCX’s “Boom Clap.” (The lyrics “on and on and on and on and” sounded like “banana-nana-nana” to him.) It’s not a hard song to enjoy, and we also enjoyed her follow-up single “Break the Rules.” (My son asked why she doesn’t want to go to school, because to a kindergartner “School is fun!”) The songs on Swift’s 1989 are similarly catchy and the videos showcase retro fashion:

 
 Hipsters have long considered the Eighties anathema, but now certain hipsters--interestingly, those too young to remember the Eighties--are mining the pop side of that decade for inspiration. For some, however, the Eighties never went away. Duran Duran, a staple of MTV in its glory years, never disbanded despite music trends turning against their style. Nonetheless, 2010’s All You Need Is Now showed the masters of the actual Eighties can still write like it’s 1986, and their recent single “Pressure Off” shows they can also write like it’s 2015, and there’s little daylight between:

 
If the pop idols of today’s youth can reach back to the New Wave for inspiration--or remakes, as with Lorde’s rendition of the Tears for Fears hit “Everybody Wants to Rule the World” (1985)--then I hope their fans will do some exploring of pop/rock history as well. And, just as importantly, I hope those of us who actually lived through 1989 can reach forward from our roots in the past to seek value in today’s vogue.