Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 6, 2016

Heracles' Hope in the Midst of Suffering


I don’t know the extent to which the culture of ancient Greece doubted its gods, but Euripides' tragedy Heracles certainly appears to question both their worthiness and existence. And when, in the course of human history, thinkers have entertained the idea that no gods exist, they always find something to replace them.

Heracles opens with the hero away performing his labours (mostly killing stuff) while an upstart ruler has evicted Heracles’ family from their home. Destitute and homeless, they supplicate Zeus for aid even as the ruler plans to execute them. At the last minute, Heracles returns, but the situation only gets worse. Hera sends Iris and Madness to drive Heracles into a frenzy during which he slays his own wife and children. When he returns to himself, he finds he has lost all by his own hands.

This story presents the gods in the worst possible light. The backstory is that Zeus cheated on Hera, sneaking into Megara’s bed and fathering Heracles. Hera exacts her revenge on Heracles and his family, using Iris and Madness as her pawns. We hear not a peep from Zeus despite all the supplication to him. Thus it’s no wonder that the characters repeatedly question the justice of the gods. After the bloodbath, Heracles openly holds the gods in disdain:
Let the glorious wife of Zeus now dance for joy and make Olympus shake with her footsteps! She has achieved her will; she has cast down from on high the foremost man of Greece, toppling him from his very foundations! What man would utter prayers to such a goddess? 
In the face of suffering, Christians claim that everything happens according to God’s will, which is unfathomable to mere mortals, but ever since antiquity, philosophers and common folk alike have seen the existence of evil and suffering as a significant challenge to the existence of any god worth the name. Would a good and all powerful god will the suffering of innocents? (previous post)

That is a riddle all believers face--as Heracles does. My copy of the play has introductory notes by Richard Rutherford, who states the play is merciless in its complete lack of hope for the hero. Instead of the deus ex machina coming at the end of the play to solve all problems, it happens halfway through and only stirs things up. And while some traditions hold that Heracles was later worshipped as payment for his suffering, Euripides has Theseus mention this briefly only to have Heracles shut him down. Nonetheless, I can’t help but disagree with Rutherford, for Euripides does indeed hold out hope.

Only it isn’t divine.

A recurring theme throughout Heracles is friendship. As the new Theban ruler Lycus subjects Heracles’ family to humiliation and worse, no one comes to their aid. The drama isn’t very long, but repeatedly the characters mention how friends tend to disappear in hard times. Amphitryon, Megara’s husband and the man who raised Heracles, states it as follows:
As for friends, some I see are not to be relied upon, while those deserving of the name are powerless to assist. So it is when men encounter misfortune. I pray that no friend of mine, even a mere acquaintance, may have this experience; there is no surer test of friends.

If Epictetus (or what I remember of his writings anyway) is anything to judge by, the vagaries of fate and the evanescent loyalty of friends are commonplace themes in ancient Greek literature, which is exactly why they stood out to me among all the more exciting elements. When you experience hard times, many friends would prefer to keep you and your affliction at an arm’s length, but a few will be there through thick and thin. This is the hope Euripides offers in a world where the gods are dubious entities at best.

This is hard to miss in the text, for not only does it show up repeatedly, but it is the note on which Euripides ends the play. Heracles is a defeated and broken demigod when his old friend Theseus shows up and offers some manly encouragement along the lines of “Quit crying and man up.” To this, Heracles is like, “Come on, everybody hurts sometimes,” and then Theseus, proving himself an understanding friend, is like, “Very well then. You’re welcome to crash at my place.”

They exit.

The caprices of fate strike us all, and when they do, maybe you turn your eyes to the heavens, maybe you don’t, maybe you feel a supernatural power answers, maybe you don’t, but undeniably the existence and qualities of any supposed divinity are uncertain. Friendship, on the other hand, while not always firm, is one hundred percent natural and experienced by all. In the absence of constant gods, we may find solace in inconstant humanity.

 

Thursday, March 17, 2016

The Ancients' Guide to Love and Sex in the 21st Century

 
"Love's not Time's fool, though rosy lips and cheeks
Within his bending sickle's compass come"
--Shakespeare, Sonnet CXVI

Plato’s Symposium opens with some Athenian luminaries attending a banquet at the tragic poet Agathon’s place. The gathering begins with everyone agreeing not to drink and ends in drunken revelry. In between, the attendees deliver speeches in praise of love, the finest of them by none other than Socrates himself. I don’t intend to offer my own encomium to love here, but I do have some thoughts on the speeches in the dialogue.

A krater depicting a symposium. I took this photo a few years ago at an exhibit of ancient Mediterranean pottery at San Francisco Airport. From my notes: Symposia were male drinking parties. Wives were excluded, but hetairai (courtesans) were welcome. Music, dancing, games and "erotic activity" were also part of symposia.


PHAEDRUS

What I find most interesting about Phaedrus’ speech is his use of the word lover. Today when we use the word lover, we usually think of one of two in a mutual romantic relationship. A close look at Phaedrus’ speech, however, shows a subtle difference. He uses the word lover to mean one who is in love with another, with reciprocity common but unnecessary. When he makes an example of Achilles and Patroclus in the Iliad, he admits Achilles’ love for Patroclus, but also makes a distinction between lover and beloved:
Very different was the reward of the true love of Achilles towards his lover Patroclus—his lover and not his love (the notion that Patroclus was the beloved one is a foolish error into which Aeschylus has fallen, for Achilles was surely the fairer of the two.

Perhaps I like this distinction on a rational level because it suggests one of the key points in the dialogue, that love is by the inferior for the superior. I decided to reread the Symposium because of references to it in Saul Bellow’s novel Ravelstein. In the novel, the narrator and titular character love each other as friends, but the narrator goes to great lengths to show that Ravelstein is the superior of the two, and thus the narrator’s devotion.

Or perhaps Phaedrus’ use of lover simply appeals to me because it allows for praise of unrequited lovers, who seek to be more virtuous and thereby win their beloved’s approval. The plight of one who moons over someone one-sidedly--a situation to which I’m no stranger--seems less unseemly when granted classical gravitas.


PAUSANIAS

Pausanias makes a distinction between high and low love:
Evil is the vulgar lover who loves the body rather than the soul, inasmuch as he is not even stable, because he loves a thing which is in itself unstable, and therefore when the bloom of youth which he was desiring is over, he takes wing and flies away, in spite of all his words and promises; whereas the love of the noble disposition is life-long, for it becomes one with the everlasting.

Judging by the jests they trade, Agathon and company have no small amount of appreciation for comely youths, so they would likely understand our modern obsession with sex, but Pausanias makes the commonplace assertion that when truly in love, you find something more in your partner. In wedding speeches and Facebook posts, husbands and wives are always talking about how “kind, caring and sweet” their partners are. This is something like that, but given how much time the great philosophers of ancient Greece spent pondering the “noble disposition,” I think Pausanias has in mind something higher than mere niceness.

But that’s for Socrates to elucidate. First, the playwright Aristophanes--of Lysistrata and Chiraq fame--makes a speech, but only after having overcome a bout of the “hiccough.”


ARISTOPHANES

Saul Bellow’s Ravelstein makes much of the sex myth in Aristophanes’ speech. The idea is that far in humanity’s past, man and woman were one being, but together they were so strong that Zeus found it necessary to weaken them by separating them. Severed from one another and finding themselves incomplete, men and women each yearned desperately for completion. Taking pity on them, Zeus provided a way for them to rejoin through love and sex. However, this was not limited to opposite-sex couples:
…or if man came to man they might be satisfied, and rest, and go their ways to the business of life: so ancient is the desire of one another which is implanted in us, reuniting our original nature, making one of two, and healing the state of man.

Certainly there is poetry in this, and I used to view the search for love in this way. A good mate fills a hole inside, completes you, shines light in your darkness. Nowadays, however, I’m more inclined to see the search for “the one” in Lacanian terms. Everyone has a hole inside that is part of their psyche and can never be filled. Two people just means two holes. Thus, Lacan says that sex--seen as the ultimate fulfillment of two individuals each in the other--is impossible (previous post).

But Aristophanes’ myth, usually deployed for its picture of two individuals coming together in perfect harmony, could also be seen as explaining the very separation described by Lacan. And even Lacan didn’t mean to say that all hope was lost. While ultimate satisfaction isn’t possible, we can’t help but search for it, and the search has its own rewards.


SOCRATES

When it’s his turn, Socrates says that love is always of the beautiful, which is the good, and one who gains the good gains happiness. Since the good for Plato is the Form by which all other forms are known, love is nothing less than a vehicle to a higher state of being:
And the true order . . . is to begin from the beauties of earth and mount upwards for the sake of that other beauty, using these as steps only, and from one going on to two, and from two to all fair forms, and from fair forms to fair practices, and from fair practices to fair notions, until from fair notions he arrives at the notion of absolute beauty, and at last knows what the essence of beauty is. This . . . is that life above all others which man should live, in the contemplation of beauty absolute.

By now we are talking about love of abstracts, of truth. Socrates typifies this latter type of love more than any other figure in the ancient world, while the love he shares with statesman and general Alcibiades--a love characterized by mutual respect and chaste nights cuddling under a blanket--represents a higher type of love between two individuals.

Does anyone experience the higher forms of love anymore? Chaste romantic relationships do exist--just ask Colin Farrell about Elizabeth Taylor--and if all my time on Twitter has taught me anything, it is that the world is full of people passionate about ideas, art and knowledge. But whatever form love takes, Socrates would tell us to do it as best we can so it makes us better people.

Socrates Seeking Alcibiades in the House of Aspasia, Jean-Léon Gérôme.
 
Previous posts mentioning Plato:

 

Tuesday, December 22, 2015

Have a Holly Jolly (and Consumerist yet Discerning) Christmas


 
These days, we’re all savvy and jaded enough to see through the misdirection of television commercials. Nonetheless, a passage about advertising in the following video caught my attention. The video is part of a series called The School of Life and summarizes the thought of Frankfurt School philosopher Theodor Adorno. It covers a lot of ground, but it isn’t long. I recommend watching the whole thing, but watch for the bit about advertising, which begins at 4:10.

 
Here's the part that jumped out at me:
“When they’re trying to sell us something, advertisers show us the thing that we really want and then connect it to something we don’t actually need. So we can see an advert showing a group of friends walking on a beach chatting amiably or a family having a picnic and laughing warmly together. These adverts show us these things because they know we crave community and connection, but the industrial economy prefers to keep us lonely and consuming, so at the end of the adverts, we’ll be urged to buy some 25-year-old whiskey or a car so powerful that no road would ever let us legally drive it at top speed.”

Advertisements do many things and one of the things they do is show us something we need in our innermost being in order to sell us something that we don’t need. Coming up with examples is easy, especially in this season when every business and corporation this side of the Industrial Revolution is trying to cash in on Christmas and financial news reports constantly tell us it is our duty to shop in order to drive up holiday sales.

Consider this Coca-Cola commercial:

 
This advertisement is full of much that we all want and need. The words kindness and joy appear in written form. We see young couples holding hands, children playing, families bonding and friends smiling. Everyone looks physically fit. A red balloon takes flight from a vending machine and drifts over a quaint plaza. Christmas gifts fall into strangers’ hands, thereby linking disparate lives against the alienating forces of modern life. The community comes together and marvels, and we are encouraged to share that old Platonic concept the Good.

Which one of us does not want such communion with our fellows? Who would pass up a chance to fall in love again? Which one of us would not like to exude such physical and spiritual well-being? Who among us does not hunger to reclaim the sense of magic we held in our youth? Who would not like to rise like the Charioteer in Plato’s Phaedrus commanding his winged steeds to climb ever higher, leaving the earth below to see with clarity the Forms and even the light of the Good?

Coca-Cola’s marketers show us these things because we need them. And they do this to sell us something no one needs: a carbonated soft drink.

Philosopher Slavoj Zizek talks about Coca-Cola in the documentary The Pervert’s Guide to Ideology (2012):

 
For Zizek, when Coca-Cola offers us “The Real Thing,” it is offering to give us l’objet petit a, the object cause of desire described in Lacanian psychoanalytic theory. The objet petit a is what we think we want, but it doesn’t really exist, so we forever circle but never grasp it. You may think you want that new car, promotion or paramour, but once you have it, are you sated? Of course not. The object cause of desire switches to something else, so you stay driven, struggling for satisfaction that, due to the makeup of our psyche, is impossible.

Pringles is so sly that its classic advertising slogan explicitly states this, keeping the objet petit a in a cycle focused solely on its own product, from chip to chip: Once you pop, you can’t stop.

But are all advertisements merely a satisfying spin on a product that ultimately provides little satisfaction? Isn’t it possible that a product satisfies what its advertisements promise? Here’s a recent commercial for the video game Star Wars Battlefront:

 
Open with palpable estrangement: a man sits bored at his desk dreaming of his childhood. Once upon a time, he and his buddy drew pictures of their action figures, they had lightsaber battles with flashlights, and they dressed up as Star Wars characters for Halloween. Those were the days . . . Then suddenly his buddy shows up in an X-Wing, he busts out of his office, boards his own fighter with its own astromech copilot (R2D2 no less!), and goes to take out some Imperial AT-ATs.

At first, this appears to be no more substantial than the Coca-Cola commercial. On that reading, this commercial offers what you really want--friendship, adventure, a sense of purpose and fulfillment--while actually offering you cheap entertainment.

But wait!

In today’s world, a video game can actually be the medium through which people connect. Through online and cooperative missions, Star Wars Battlefront allows players to meet and play with strangers, or play together with your favorite mop-headed childhood buddy. And while the adventures are all virtual, this has always been the nature of storytelling and takes nothing away from the magic. Star Wars and other franchises are no less inspiring to many than the plays of Euripides once were to Athenians, or Beowulf to the Anglo-Saxons. Star Wars Battlefront isn’t exactly necessary, but it has the potential to facilitate some things we truly need.

I’m more skeptical that a can of Coca-Cola can be as successful at slaking spiritual thirst, but perhaps I’m being too harsh. How many cans of Mr. Pibb have I enjoyed with friends over tabletop RPGs, sharing laughs and having a hell of a time? The beverage was a part of that, a part of our subculture, our fraternity.

As usual, I see the value in multiple perspectives, but that can be a good thing. I guarantee you will watch television this Christmas season, see the same commercials over and over until you want to start chucking nutcracker soldiers at the screen, and spend too much money on crap for yourself and others. In today’s world, you can’t help but be a consumer, which is to say a stooge to the boob tube, but you can also remember to check yourself, see through the haze of price tags and twinkling lights, and seek a holiday experience that holds something more authentic.

 

Thursday, August 13, 2015

Voting and the Engine of History


 
Marxists speak of permanent revolution, so it’s only natural that in capitalist America we should have something different: permanent election. The two major parties never cease spouting empty rhetoric and smearing the other side, and what is simply sad the day after one election increases to a farcical fervor as the next approaches. We can understand then if sensible folk--regular folk whose lives are increasingly dominated by labor for diminishing returns--should turn away from the system in exhaustion and cynicism and refuse to vote. In this post, I want to examine this in light of two philosophical concepts.

I just finished reading the novel Seeing by Jose Saramago. It’s election day in the capital, but hardly anyone shows up at the polling stations. When the populace finally does appear, more than 70% of the voters leave their ballots blank. A recall leads to an even higher percentage of blank votes, throwing the government into confusion. The powers that be resort to various dishonest maneuvers and draconian measures, but the people, at least at first, outwit them at every step by refusing the play the government’s game.

In his book In Defense of Lost Causes, philosopher Slavoj Zizek designates the refusal to vote in Seeing as an instance of subtraction. He makes the point that not just any failure to vote equals a political action--laziness or mere cynicism will not suffice--and suggests that the action is fruitless if it doesn’t reach critical mass: 
“So when is subtraction really creative of a new space? The only appropriate answer: when it undermines the coordinates of the very system from which it subtracts itself . . . Imagine the proverbial house of cards or a pile of wooden pieces which rely on one another in such a complex way that, if one single card or piece of wood is pulled out--subtracted--the whole edifice collapses: this is the true art of subtraction." 

The other concept comes to us from the Frankfurt School, which was particularly influential in the mid-20th Century. The philosophers of this group were often skeptical of the very possibility of concrete means of resistance. Critical theory was heavily influenced by Marxism, so capitalism serves as an apt illustration due to its uncanny ability to swallow everything, even opposition, and turn it to its benefit. To take an example from the trends of our own day, capitalism is a driving force behind environmental destruction, so your eco-friendly start-up is only part of the problem.

“If the totally administered society is truly total, and capable of integrating and domesticating all critical undertakings, then the prospects for political action are dim. Resistance as political practice is a worthless enterprise. The negation is the only available option, and negative dialectics must define the critical enterprise.”

Philosophers before the Frankfurt School envisioned history much the way Hegel did: as a march forward driven by opposing forces. As Hegel is usually summarized, thesis gives rise to an antithesis, which results in a synthesis. This synthesis becomes a new thesis that invites a new antithesis, and so on. This process was seen as the engine of progress leading us all to an ever better world. Thus, in The Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels speak of the conflict between feudal lords and serfs as giving rise to the bourgeoisie, which was in turn opposed by the proletariat, preparing the way for a communist utopia--which they saw as the end point of history’s development.

That’s all forward-looking and follows an agenda, but critical theorist Theodor Adorno proposed a negative dialectics that sought to further the negative (the antithesis) for a break with current realities even if the result isn’t positive and doesn’t lead to some synthesis preordained by the existing paradigm. This opens new possibilities that could never have arisen out of the old order. For Adorno and others of the Frankfurt School, that meant greater freedom--not just the freedom to do this or that (e.g., to marry whomever you please, to own a semi-automatic firearm), but freedom that begins in an individual’s consciousness.

Call it deep liberation.

Apply the basic idea of negative dialectics to American politics. If the main dueling forces are the Republicans and Democrats, then a vote for either party is a vote for the status quo that is the synthesis they generate. To break the cycle and be free of the system’s constraints, you must undercut the whole triad, the whole power structure. You might attempt this by refusing to vote.

Some individuals intend to do just that in the upcoming presidential election.  On Twitter, I have seen the hashtag #NoVote2016. Those who use it say they will not vote because none of the candidates represent what in their minds would constitute a substantive change. Even a candidate like democratic socialist Bernie Sanders (running as a Democrat), whose platform is further left than we’re accustomed to seeing from a major candidate, is unfit in their eyes because on some issues he holds close to the status quo. For example, they say he does not address race issues satisfactorily and that he sides with Israel in its occupation of Palestine. They also do not like the way he would continue America’s military presence around the world, including the use of drones, albeit in a more judicious manner.

When sticking points are at stake, I can understand and respect why someone would choose not to participate in the system, but I would strongly encourage them to rethink this.

I would feel better about not voting in 2016 if it would make a statement, but it won’t. For most of my life, voter turnout in federal elections has been in the 30-50% range. In the 2014 midterm elections, it was 36.3%. In Japan, voter turnout in the same decades has been around 50%-70%. A presidential election in France can hit 80%. Suppose #NoVote2016 catches on spectacularly and drops the percentage of voters to 18%, half the rate in 2014. The powers that be will not care. They don’t want to hear from you anyway. Hell, the GOP has been pushing voter suppression measures for years. Our legislators are a class all their own and the less they have to worry about what the riffraff in the street has to say, the better for their interests.

Thus, this subtraction will not constitute a positive act. And it remains highly questionable as negative dialectics, because negative dialectics itself is highly questionable. Even the philosophers of the Frankfurt School were unsure of its efficacy--and critics were even more skeptical. Can doing nothing really have much of an effect, and if not, what is the point?

Can we, then, imagine a positive difference within the dynamics of the election? Considering that many of the people promoting #NoVote2016 are somewhere on the left, the answer is no. By refusing to cast their votes for candidates on the left, they play into the hands of the right--which tends to pull together better. You think things are bad for progressive causes now, give the country to the next Ronald Reagan or George W. Bush and see how you like things then. That’s setting America back another decade, which equals more suffering for more people. Historically, a common failing of the radical left has been that its methods for helping people often involve hurting more people in the meantime until its final objectives are reached, until the perfect order arrives.

And how often does that happen?

I guess that makes me a proponent of the “lesser of two evils” approach, which some view as spineless and naïve. Whereas the Frankfurt School was often intensely skeptical of the possibility of change and the #NoVote2016 crowd is in my opinion driven by idealism, I have come to value the gradualism of American pragmatism, which doesn't demand sweeping changes to the social order overnight--much less the initiation of an ideal order--but rather struggles to make continuous smaller changes. Surely this is what the word progressive originally meant.

If the GOP’s vision of America is yours, by all means vote for Republican candidates, but otherwise find others to vote for so they can support your aims. My own choice is to support Bernie Sanders now--despite not finding him perfect--because of his commitment to the working class, and later I will grit my teeth and support Hillary Clinton as a strategic maneuver to prevent a Jeb Bush presidency--but there are other candidates out there. No candidate is flawless, but some can deliver, if not perfection in our time, then at least progress in our time.

The powers that be can control the airwaves, ignore your tweets, crack down on your protest, and try to influence your vote, but they still have to count your vote. Don’t miss your opportunity to cast it.

 

Tuesday, June 9, 2015

Helloween Hermeneutics


I arrived late to the Helloween game--as late as Straight Out of Hell, which was released in 2013. That’s 29 years after the band’s debut album and long after the classic albums that established the band for all eternity in power-metaldom. Last week, when Helloween released My God-Given Right, I found its cover to be an interesting text for interpretive exploration.

 
At first, I wondered if the image was intended to express anti-American sentiment. Helloween is a German band and Europe has its share of anti-American sentiment. On the album cover, the band has chosen to show the Statue of Liberty buried in snow up to her eyeballs against a frozen urban skyline suggestive of Manhattan, while a figure stands atop her head inciting a horde of minions that has triumphed in America’s downfall.

In this context, the title My God-Given Right would be an ironical jab at America’s belief in its divine appointment to conquer and civilize the world. This belief is explicitly stated in the doctrine of Manifest Destiny and remains operative to this day. The album art could be saying “Like Rome, your empire will fall. This is what will become of your hubris.”

But is that really what the cover is saying? Turning to the song “Lost in America” for a nitty-gritty critique of America, I instead find lyrics based on a true story about the group being drunk and high on an airplane with faulty gauges somewhere over the United States:

 
That’s hardly piquant social critique, but there is more than a “plunder the sky bar” mentality behind the image. Occasional Helloween cover artist Martin Häusler explained his thought process to Blabbermouth:

During my research, I stumbled upon the blockbuster Day After Tomorrow and the idea of just leaving the world to the “Pumpkins” was born.

In this light, it is not just America but all of human civilization that has fallen. The folly of those who pull the world’s strings has finally brought us to apocalypse, perhaps through nuclear war or environmental catastrophe. One song on the album, “The Swing of a Fallen World,” laments what may become of our world if The Powers That Be do not change their ways:
The treasure we had so crazy and mad
Was sold out by people who cannot be glad
A handful of greed
A contagious seed
A handful of assholes who never recede
This adverse evolution
Mankind knows no solution
It’s the swing of a fallen world
For all that, My God-Given Right is not a dark album. The cover suggests a brighter world to come, for when the mighty fall, little people rise up. In this case, the little people are the “Pumpkins”--humanoids with jack-o'-lantern heads that represent the band and its Pumpkinhead fans.

What would a world ruled by Pumpkinheads be like? Well for one thing, it would be crazy in true heavy-metal style: booze, loud music and late nights. Helloween sings about this lifestyle in “Stay Crazy.” However, according to lead vocalist Andi Deris, the song “My God-Given Right” was inspired by words his father said to encourage him in a life of music:
 
He said, “You’re my only son. If I see you happy, you make me happy and it’s your God-given right to do what you want with your life, or at least give it a try.

Freedom to do what you want. Comments made by Helloween’s band members suggest they have faced opposition throughout their lives and careers for being different, and this theme runs throughout their music, from lyrics to musical style. Like most metal bands, Helloween has come under fire anytime it does anything different, but for artists, exploring new creative avenues is the stuff of life. A world run by Pumpkins would be one in which people follow their bliss1 and no one lets the bastards grind you down.2

Or is that all wrong? The video for “My God-Given Right” keeps the theme of individual freedom, but shows a lone female rebel fighting against shock troops in pumpkin helmets--which makes the pumpkins the bad guys. Furthermore, she eventually defeats them with grenades that briefly take on the appearance of the Statue of Liberty’s torch--which could be construed as pro-American.

 
Thankfully, interpretation as well as heavy metal is more about play3 than restrictive definitions and theories, so there is no need to search for the correct meaning behind the cover of My God-Given Right. The album rocks, the cover is cool, and both provide food for thought.


Footnotes:
1. Comparative mythologist Joseph Campbell's advice for fulfillment in life.
2. Drawing on lyrics from U2's "Acrobat."
3. A concept in the writings of philosopher Hans-Georg Gadamer.
 

Sunday, April 26, 2015

Eternal Recurrence and Nietzsche (1/4)


Eternal recurrence is one of Friedrich Nietzsche’s more far-fetched concepts and thus one that philosophers have long looked at askance. And yet it remains an attractive concept and has a powerful effect in works of fiction--usually in corrupt but nonetheless enlightening forms.

The nut of Nietzsche’s idea isn’t hard to understand. Here is an explanation from The Gay Science:

What if a demon crept after you one day or night in your loneliest solitude and said to you: ‘This life, as you live it now and have lived it, you will have to live again and again, times without number; and there will be nothing new in it, but every pain and every joy and every thought and sigh and all the unspeakably small and great in your life must return to you, and everything in the same series and sequence.

The basis for the idea is that in the vast expanse of infinite time a finite number of matter particles rearranging themselves in finite space will at some point fall into the same forms and repeat everything in exactly the same way. According to William Kaufmann in Nietzsche, scientists have shown this is not necessarily true, but Nietzsche was less concerned with whether eternal recurrence actually happens than he was with what it would mean to someone to believe it were true:


Would you not throw yourself down and gnash your teeth and curse the demon who thus spoke? Or have you experienced a tremendous moment in which you would have answered him: ‘You are a god and never did I hear anything more divine!’ If this thought gained power over you it would, as you are now, transform and perhaps crush you.

I wrote about this before in my post “Amor Fati and the Birth of a Child,” in which I discussed how the birth of my son and his continuing presence in my life causes me to accept everything that has happened in my past, both good and bad. He is my “tremendous moment,” and a demon whispering in my ear that I must repeat my life with all its sufferings over again would be a god to me for he would also be giving me the chance to re-experience all those precious moments with my son.

Eternal recurrence features heavily in Irvin D. Yalom’s When Nietzsche Wept, a novel that tells the story of what might have happened had Josef Breuer, one of the first psychoanalysts, applied his “talking cure” to a despairing Nietzsche. As the two meet and discuss life, Breuer at times becomes the analysand and Nietzsche the analyst. When the philosopher suggests his “thought experiment” of eternal recurrence, Breuer is horrified. He cannot bear the thought of revisiting all of life’s indignities (career angst, marital infidelity, etc.), but the idea has a therapeutic effect on Nietzsche.

 
Recurrence both eternal and temporary, sometimes bound with reincarnation, is a common theme in fiction. Eternal recurrence serves as the cosmological backdrop to Robert Jordan’s series of fantasy novels The Wheel of Time and I recently ran across an example of temporary recurrence in the Farscape episode “Back and Back and Back to the Future.” In this series of posts, I will discuss the recent movie Edge of Tomorrow, the classic romantic comedy Groundhog Day, and the concept’s unusual treatment by Milan Kundera in his novel The Unbearable Lightness of Being.

 
 

Friday, February 13, 2015

The Philosophy of Zombie Strippers


Woefully unimportant things have a way of lodging in my brain, so I never forgot about the unexpected success of Zombie Strippers back in 2008. When I ran across the DVD recently, I picked it up out of curiosity and was pleased to find it references several major philosophers.

When a facility running tests on zombies shares a building with a strip club, the worst is bound to happen. A zombie escapes and bites a pole dancer and it’s all downhill from there. The strippers feed on their clientele, discolor, and fall apart, but they keep on gyrating and peeling off garments. Eventually, the guns come out and the gore ramps up even further.
 
Surprisingly, Zombie Strippers is a cut above your usual B-movie about zombies or strippers, so if any of the above sounds intriguing, knock yourself out and look for these nods to great thinkers.
 


 
SOCRATES (470/469-399 BC)

Early in the film, the strip club DJ introduces the next dancer to take the floor:

“Now Bobby Sox, is gonna tease you with her Socrates!”

You caught the pun, right? Socrates was the ancient Greek philosopher made to drink hemlock for corrupting the youth of Athens. It was his habit to hang out in the agora, the city’s public gathering space, to discuss the issues of the day: What is the perfect form of society? Is there an afterlife? What is the nature of language? Much of what we know about Socrates comes to us through the writings of other ancients, most notably the dialogues of Plato.

Plato’s dialogues showcase a form of discussion lacking in public discourse today. Typically, the interlocutors will venture their respective ideas of, say, justice, and then make rational objections to each other’s hypotheses. Often, when reason reveals a flaw in an argument, its purveyor will abandon or revise his position. The result is a conversation that makes progress, steadily drawing near a more perfect conception of the truth. When was the last time a talking head on television showed any capacity for backing down in the face of a superior argument?

 


RENÉ DESCARTES (1596-1650)

Proceeding forward along the history of philosophy, our next thinker appears as the club descends into mayhem. A stripper and her ditzy boyfriend confront a soldier hunting zombies. The soldier demands that they say something human to prove they aren't zombies, and the boyfriend does his best:

“Uh . . . shit! Could you give me something easier? Okay, okay! Um, I think therefore I am. I think? Actually, I have doubts about that one.”


“I think therefore I am” is the common English translation of French philosopher René Descartes’ Latin dictum Cogito ergo sum. Descartes wanted to set the sciences on a firm foundation but realized our senses often deceive us. In fact, it was possible to doubt just about everything. He even considered the possibility that the whole world was but a dream concocted by an evil daemon. So he looked around for one thing he couldn’t doubt, something solid to serve as a beginning point for constructing an entire system of knowledge, and--Voilà!--he realized that with all this doubting (thinking) going on, the existence of a doubter (the self) was certain.
 
 
Philosophers never let a good a proposition stand, so they have poked holes in this elegant maxim in the centuries since it appeared in Discourse on Method (1637). However, while it would be faint consolation to the philosophe, I still think we can say his first principle is pretty good.

 


FRIEDRICH NIETZSCHE (1844-1900)

Earlier in the film, Kat (played by porn star Jenna Jameson) is in the dressing room reading The Complete Works of Friedrich Nietzsche and even quotes it:

“That which doesn’t kill us makes us stronger, right?”


Okay, most of us know that one, but she can do even better:

“Yeah sure, but everything great must first wear a hideous and monstrous mask in order to inscribe themselves on the hearts of humanity.”

Friedrich Nietzsche is a philosopher dear to me, although it has been years since I read and reread most of his major works. The first quote is from Twilight of the Idols (1888). The second has proven harder to pinpoint, but it may be from Beyond Good and Evil (1886), so Kat appears to have made it to the later Nietzsche.

Nietzsche remains a scary philosopher in the public imagination because of his bombastic writing style, iconoclastic quotes like “God is dead” and concepts like the will to power. Unfortunately, his ideas were not fully understood or even widely available until long after they had been purveyed in a twisted form by his sister and some of the 19th-Century’s worst political actors. The Übermensh, for example, describes an individual who is superior through self-overcoming, with no need to seek validation through power over others (previous post). In fact--if I remember my Walter Kaufmann correctly--Nietzsche was considered by many of his contemporaries to be a soft-spoken and polite fellow.

 


JEAN-PAUL SARTRE (1905-1980)

The philosophical references in Zombie Strippers are too numerous and forced not to be an intentional motif. When aspiring stripper Jessy is walking home one night, she passes a large sign bearing the name of her fictional hometown: SARTRE, NEBRASKA.

Jean-Paul Sartre, while not generally considered the handsomest of philosophers, was nonetheless able to convince his romantic partner, early feminist thinker and philosopher Simone de Beauvoir, that an open relationship would be a good idea so he could entertain a young Algerian mistress whom he later adopted as a daughter.

JP--as I assume his amants knew him--is known as one of the great existentialist philosophers. In a wonderful essay entitled “What Is Existentialism?” he explains that whereas for centuries we have been taught that our essence (our soul) exists first and then comes to inhabit the flesh in existence, it’s actually the other way around. We are born, and through the experience of living in existence, we determine our essence. The choices you make, with no confidant but your own conscience, determine who you are. This is Descartes in reverse: I am, therefore I think.



Conclusion

What does all of this philosophy have to do with the deeper content of Zombie Strippers? At first, I was tempted to say there is no deeper content to Zombie Strippers--after all, it has a bit about a zombie firing pool balls out of her vagina--but the film actually makes an effort to comment on the cheap thrills pervasive in America today, cheap thrills that the movie itself represents but also underscores through references to our rich heritage of philosophical thought.

I would say all the philosophy I’ve described above is Philosophy 101, but of the above thinkers, I only studied Socrates and Descartes as an undergrad. I had to study Nietzsche and Sartre on my own, so I guess that makes this a notch above Philosophy 101. But that doesn’t spare this from being one of the most pointless blog posts ever.